Skip to content

Design Your Own Delight

At Covenant Cookie Creations, every shortbread-style sugar cookie is a work of art. Over a three-day process, one baker handcrafts each cookie from beginning to end, topping it with royal icing and custom-decorating it for weddings, baby showers, holidays, sports, and corporate events.
Order Now
Handmade Cookies

Our Story

I’m Michele Pavlich, founder of Covenant Cookie Creations, LLC, established in 2024 and based in Miramar Beach, Florida. After 25 years as a military spouse and celebrating 40 years of marriage, I wanted to share more than just cookies, I wanted to share joy, love, and faith. Our roots trace back to Elyria, Ohio, where the idea for Covenant Cookie Creations bloomed during our 40th wedding anniversary. It wasn’t just about baking; it was something more profound.

Today, I pour that same love and care into every cookie. Using the finest ingredients and a personal touch, each order is designed to reflect life’s sweetest moments. From weddings and baby showers to holidays and business events, Covenant Cookie Creations is here to bring joy, one cookie at a time.

Delicious Cookies

Artistic Creations

Our sugar cookies will transport you back to your grandmother’s kitchen, stirring memories of warmth, love, and childhood wonder. Each one is a whimsical masterpiece — a taste of tradition, a touch of artistry, and a whole lot of deliciousness. Handcrafted just for you and your event, these cookies are personalized with creativity and baked with love.

Testimonials

Fresh from the Oven

Tarter Family _JPG
The cookies tasted absolutely great! Thank you so much for making our vacation that much more enjoyable!
Pamela T. and Family
unnamed (6)
My boys loved the cookies, all of them! Taylor said, "I loved the flavor from my first bite to the last. No complaints here. Tell her I said hey."
Tracey M.
Bess & Josh3
These look great, can't wait to try them!
Bess and Josh
Kuch4
The cookies look too good to eat!
Mike and Jody K.
22
The cookies were absolutely delicious, the design/Logo was spot-on, and the packaging very professional, a wonderful addition to our Annual Dinner!
Emerald Coast PMI Chapter
Bradley
We absolutely love the cookies!
Kayla & Maria B.
unnamed (5)
Oh, my goodness! I just received the cookies, and they are packaged so beautifully in boxes and bows. What an incredible presentation!
Terri B.
test_Pic
Thank you for the awesome cookies!
Barb S.
unnamed
Very Pretty! And the packaging as far as shipping I think was great. The bubble wrap and everything. No broken cookies!
Beth M.
Devina
Great, they all loved the cookies!
Devina

Get Your Order Started

We customize each cookie design for your special events like birthdays, weddings, holidays, corporate gifts, and more.

Cookie Pricing: ½ Dozen (6) for $30 minimum order. Dozen (12) for $50 (discount from $60). Large orders (60+ cookies) receive custom discounted pricing.

Fill out the form below and our team will contact you with a personalized quote and to create your custom design.

Each cookie is sealed for freshness up to 3 weeks. Shipping is billed separately within the continental U.S.
Proudly following Florida Cottage Food Guidelines.